Mobile Menu
Offshore Cases

In Primeo Fund (In Official Liquidation) and Bank of Bermuda (Cayman) Limited, HSBC Securities Services (Luxembourg) SA

March 2020 AppealLiquidation

CAYMAN ISLANDS

Court of Appeal

The common law principle of reflective loss has been judicially described as a “perplexing and developing area”. The most recent decision of the Court of Appeal in the Cayman Islands has highlighted the importance of paying close attention to the scope and application of the principle.

On 13 June 2019 the Cayman Islands Court of Appeal gave judgment in Primeo Fund (In Official Liquidation) and Bank of Bermuda (Cayman) Limited, HSBC Securities Services (Luxembourg) SA in which it held that recovery by Primeo of losses caused by the administrators and custodian of the feeder funds, through which they were invested in Bernard L Madoff Investment Securities LLC (“BLMIS”), were barred by the principle of reflective loss, even though wrongdoing had been established.

Originally Primeo had invested directly in BLMIS, but later, in 2003, it had changed to investing indirectly through two feeder funds, Herald Fund SPC (“Herald”) and Alpha Prime Fund Ltd. (“Alpha”). At first instance, the Judge had held that it was irrelevant that when the cause of action arose Primeo was not a shareholder in Herald or Alpha, and that, provided there was a real prospect of success of a claim by Herald or Alpha succeeding, Primeo’s claim would be barred by the principle of reflective loss. This decision was upheld on appeal.

The reflective loss principle applies where a shareholder12 and a company both have a claim against a defendant arising out of the same facts. Unless all or part of the shareholder’s loss is separate and distinct from the loss suffered by the company it will not be recoverable in an action brought by the shareholder against the defendant.

 

To continue reading full articles in PDF format:
In Primeo Fund (In Official Liquidation) and Bank of Bermuda (Cayman) Limited, HSBC Securities Services (Luxembourg) SA

 

Accolades
_

"I enjoy working with them - they are very dependable, reliable and responsive."
- Chambers Global